A Look at the 2011 NFL Draft First Round Quarterbacks From a Fantasy Perspective

Apr 29, 2011


.

Obviously quarterbacks were big early, with none bigger than Cam Newton. He should have no trouble beating out Jimmy Clausen as long as he’s able to get the reps to learn the playbook. The labor situation comes into play once again. He’s a bit of a risk as a dynasty quarterback. You just don’t know how he’ll fair at the next level. He is an amazing athlete though that has major upside.
.
With the Steve Smith era likely over, Newton will be working with David Gettis and Brandon LaFell. Not exactly the who’s who of NFL receivers, but they showed some flashes last year. Given the quarterback issues in Carolina last year, it’s not really fair to give them a grade.
.
The loser is this draft pick, aside from the obvious choice of Jimmy Clausen, is Jonathan Stewart. Newton is a gifted runner that will vulture some of his would be rushing touchdowns.
.
Jake Locker found a good landing place. Who wouldn’t want to have Chris Johnson in the backfield and Kenny Britt (assuming he doesn’t get himself arrested or suspended) to throw to? Accuracy has been an issue for Locker, but Britt has the ability to erase mistakes. While he doesn’t have the upside of Newton, he could turn into a solid NFL (and fantasy) quarterback.
.
I would take Blaine Gabbert over Locker in dynasty leagues, but Locker is probably the second quarterback (behind Newton) that I would take in redraft leagues. We’ll have to see how the rest of the draft and free agency period plays out before I make a firm assessment.
.
Blaine Gabbert landed in a good place for him. He will be afforded the time to develop playing behind David Garrard. Garrard, who learned under Byron Leftwich, is a good team player and will be suitable teacher for Gabbert. The pick doesn’t affect the skill position players as he won’t likely take the field unless things go sour of the Jags.
.
One long-term concern is the hot seat the Jack Del Rio seems to continually be on. If he loses his job, will a new coach want to make his mark with his own guy? Especially if he does play and stink it up, a la Jimmy Clausen. That is back-of-the-mind concern though and shouldn’t have too much weight in your decision to take him in dynasty drafts.
.
Finally we come to Christian Ponder, a pick that did not go over well with Vikings fans. He’s smart, with enough athleticism and accuracy to make him a quality NFL quarterback. Injuries have dogged him the past couple of years, but the jury is certainly still out on him in that regard. I think he’ll be a solid pro, I just don’t know that the Vikings wouldn’t have been better served taking Nick Fairley, Mike Pouncey, or Prince Amukamara with the 12th pick and went after a quarterback in the second round.
.
Ponder has one of the best running backs in the game (Adrian Peterson) to hand off to and a gifted receiver in Percy Harvin. Sidney Rice may have leave via free agency, but the Vikings have been committed to addressing needs under Zygi Wilf. The Vikings will add a veteran quarterback, but we’ll have to wait and see if it is to be a mentor or a stopgap.

. .

3 Responses so far | Have Your Say!

  1. Minnesota Vikings Fail To Address Need With Second Pick | NFL Touchdown
    April 29th, 2011 at 8:41 pm #

    [...] 2011 NFL Draft First Round Quarterbacks [...]

  2. Minnesota Vikings Fail To Address Need With Second Pick | twelveoclock.info
    April 30th, 2011 at 4:21 am #

    [...] 2011 NFL Draft First Round Quarterbacks [...]

  3. Vikings Make Good Call With Christian Ballard | NFL Touchdown
    April 30th, 2011 at 11:24 am #

    [...] 2011 NFL Draft First Round Quarterbacks [...]

Leave a Comment


Partner of USA TODAY Sports Digital Properties