NFL Backup QBs: Break Glass in Case of Emergency

Aug 25, 2009

Yesterday, we looked at Mancuso’s top RB handcuffs, guys you should stash away in case your Stud RB goes down.  Now let’s take a look at some QBs that you could be forced to grab if your top QB goes down.  It’s a safer practice to draft a good backup, but last year guys like Matt Cassel and even Tyler Thigpen to a degree were fantasy saviors. 

Matt Leinart, Arizona Cardinals – Perhaps the best of the bunch based on Kurt Warner’s age and the fleet of WRs at his disposal should he get thrown in the mix.  If Kurt went down I would immediately make a play for Leinart.  Many feel like he’ll never make an impact in this league, but I think he’s been humbled enough that he would make the most out of his next opportunity.

Derek Anderson/Brady Quinn, Cleveland Browns - It appears as if Quinn will win the starting QB gig for the Browns.  If the starter were to go down, the backup would have some value as a fantasy backup.

Jon Kitna, Dallas Cowboys - Kitna has something left in the tank and a familiarity with Cowboys #1 WR Roy Williams.  With a strong ground game behind him, an elite TE in Jason Witten, and several solid WRs (Roy, Miles Austin, Patrick Crayton) Kitna would be worth grabbing off the waiver wire.  If he proved his worth in his first couple of starts then I would consider rolling with him given the right matchup.

Chris Simms, Denver Broncos - Simms would be a possibility if Orton went down or struggled.  The Broncos have plenty of weapons on offense with Brandon Marshall, Eddie Royal, Tony Scheffler, and Knowshon Moreno, that Simms could be a decent spot start in a pinch.

Brodie Croyle, Kansas City Chiefs - Don’t laugh, but I think Croyle could be a decent play in Todd Haley’s offense if Cassel were to go down.  There’s actually been some talk that he coudl push Cassel for the starting gig.  I don’t buy it, but he could make for a short leash for Cassel.

Sage Rosenfels, Minnesota Vikings - Sage has been there, done that as far as stepping in to replace a fallen starter.  Of course, that is unheard of with Brett Favre, but you never know.  The Vikings certainly have enough weapons at his disposal if he did get the call.  I just wouldn’t hold your breath.

Kevin O’Connell/Andrew Walter, New England Patriots - Could lightning strike twice?  I hope not, but I wouldn’t doubt that either of these guys could get it done with those weapons in that system.

Kevin Kolb, Philadelphia Eagles - The weapons are there.  Kolb could be a solid replacement as long as Vick didn’t see a big increase in his role.

Don’t Bother with their Backups:
Atlanta  – If Matt Ryan goes down, look elsewhere.
Baltimore – Flacco is barely worth owning.
Buffalo – Edwards goes down and they just run more.
Carolina – Ditto.
Chicago – Cutler goes down, stay away.
Cincinnati – Though J.T. O’Sullivan is better than what they had, he’s not good enough.
Detroit – I wouldn’t own Stafford or Culpepper.
Green Bay – Don’t trust either second-year QBs.
Houston – Their good backup is now a Viking.
Indianapolis – Too much of a timing offense.
Jacksonville – Todd Bouman?  No thanks.
Miami – Henne or Pennington are close, but wouldn’t want either.
New Orleans – Joey?  Brunell.  Yuck.
New York Giants – With those wides, I’ll pass.
New York Jets – Unless Sanchez is the backup, then maybe.
Oakland – Really?  Even Jeff Garcia couldn’t salvage that bunch.
Pittsburgh - I think the Steelers would just run more.
San Diego – Not much after Rivers
San Francisco – I don’t like any of their QBs.
St. Louis – Kyle Boller doesn’t do it for me.
Tampa Bay – I don’t think they have the weapons for a viable fantasy QB.
Tennessee – You trusting Vince Young?
Washington – Todd Collins was good in 2007.  At 37 I just don’t trust him anymore.  I don’t know that Colt is ready.

Save $80 on’s Fantasy Football Commisioner league with the exclusive LestersLegends discount code.   Sign up today!

Posted by | Categories: Fantasy Football, NFL | Tagged: backup QBs, Fantasy Football, NFL |
. .

5 Responses so far | Have Your Say!

  1. Brad
    August 25th, 2009 at 8:17 am #

    I’ve seen the Panthers’ backup QB’s in game action against 2nd and 3rd team defenses. Trust me – DO NOT TAKE THEM. YOU WILL LOSE. They can’t even make plays against guys who will be working at Wal-Mart next week.

  2. LestersLegends
    August 25th, 2009 at 8:19 am #

    Funny Brad.

  3. Brad
    August 25th, 2009 at 9:44 am #

    The sad thing is that I’m not trying to be funny – lol. They really are that bad.

  4. LestersLegends
    August 25th, 2009 at 9:46 am #

    I know, but it was funny. Not for your team though. Stay upright Delhomme.

  5. NFL Backup QBs: Break Glass in Case of Emergency | Sports Fan Goods
    August 28th, 2009 at 6:59 am #

    [...] Read more from the original source [...]

Leave a Comment

Partner of USA TODAY Sports Digital Properties